Study shows that belo monte is the cheapest and cleanest alternative for elektroproduktado. Mar 21, 2015 brazil plans to build 43 large dams 30 mw in the tapajos basin, ten of which are priorities for completion by 2022. But the environmental impact assessment eia provides no details regarding the interaction between both projects, neither their accumulative impact. Over the decades the name of the project has changed along with its design and principle source of financing, but the brazilian governments insistence of damming the xingu river in. The environmental impact assessment eia, funded by codevasf argues that the yields from irrigated riceplots would be higher than from the traditional planting methods of the villagers. O escopo do presente estudo compreende as informacoes gerais, caracterizacao do empreendimento, diagnostico ambiental, analise integrada do meio ambiente. Til date begin of 2019, it is still only partly operating. Analise comparativa entre belo monte e empreendimentos alternativos. The planned installed capacity of the dam complex would be 11,233 megawatts mw, which would make it the secondlargest hydroelectric dam complex in brazil and one of the worlds largest in installed capacity, behind the three gorges dam. Also, the plan would create a larger number of jobs. The new head of the licensing department was then promoted to head ibama, and approved the installation license in that capacity. Environmental impact assessment in brazilian amazonia. The impacts of hydroelectric dams on smallscale fisheries may have been underestimated.
Conflict in the amazonthe belo monte dam, yale 360 directed and produced by charles lyons duration. Carbon credit is granted to hydroelectric dams under the united nations framework convention on climate change kyoto protocols clean development mechanism cdm under the assumptions that 1 the dams would not be built without cdm funding and 2 over the 7 to 10year duration of the projects the dams would have minimal emissions as compared to the fossil fuelgenerated electricity they. After its completion, with the installation of its 18th turbine, on november 2019, the installed capacity of the dam complex is 11,233 megawatts mw, which makes it the second largest hydroelectric dam complex in brazil and fourth largest in the. Here we provide an overview of the efficiency of eia with emphasis on brazilian amazonia and discuss the problems. Belo monte is a gigantic hyroelectric project on the xingu river, under construction since 2011 and partly operational since 2015. Furthermore, this project will be only 11 km away from the belo monte dam which will increase the environmental damage.
Brazil has extensive plans for inland navigation fearnside 2001, 2002. Carbon credit is granted to hydroelectric dams under the united nations framework convention on climate change kyoto protocols clean development mechanism cdm under the assumptions that 1 the dams would not be built without cdm funding and 2 over the 7 to 10year duration of the projects the dams would have minimal emissions as compared to the fossil fuel. Belo monte dam wikipedias belo monte dam as translated by. Gestao ambiental eia e rima by joele segala on prezi. This inaugurated a new period in licensing, in which any project can be approved no matter how severe its impacts see discussion of the belo monte dam in fearnside, 2012. Environmentalists, indigenous groups, rocks stars and hollywood heavyhitters have had it in for the belo monte hydroelectric dam project since brazils military dictatorship schemed up the idea some 30 years ago. Greenhouse gas emissions from brazils amazonian hydroelectric dams. Fishers knowledge indicates extensive socioecological. Over the decades the name of the project has changed along with its design and. O eia rima da usina hidreletrica belo monte e as populacoes indigenas. Sumcrio apresenta o 12 resumo executivo 14 executive summary 16 1.
The belo monte hydroelectric dam project amazon watch. Though the plan of the belo monte dam and the vast economic advantages that accompany it may seem ideal for brazil, there are numerous disadvantages to the project. This document introduces rima ii, the technical evolution of the fao resilience index measurement and analysis rima tool. Tour graphically shows impacts of belo monte and 60 other dams planned for amazon. The results show that most of the exploited fish would be affected by the planned dam, and thus the. Dams flood rapids that impede navigation and the locks associated with the dams allow the passage of barges. It was not until 2006 that the work on the eia resumed again, and it was of. After the flood, by filmmaker todd southgate and coproduced by amazon watch, international rivers, and cultures of resistance, explores the history and consequences of one of the worlds most controversial dam projects, built on the xingu river in the heart of the brazilian amazon. The economic unviability of belo monte without upstream dams to store water for use during the dry season has been interpreted as implying that there will be a 10. The belo monte eia is descriptive rather than predictive, and it falls short of proposing mitigating actions appendix 2 in online supplementary material. This chapter presents the history of hydroelectricity and the construction of hydroelectric dams in brazil.
Impacts include flooding indigenous lands and conservation units. Apr 03, 2017 the economic unviability of belo monte without upstream dams to store water for use during the dry season has been interpreted as implying that there will be a 10. Territorial and spatial effects of dams springerlink. Development blind spots and environmental impact assessment. The eia further lacks analyses of synergistic effects, environmental effects due to the human population attracted to the area, increase in deforestation, and changes in the flood cycle. In this study, we estimated fisheries vulnerability downstream of a proposed dam through interviews with 171 fishers in 16 communities along a. This is because it was not planned or discussed as a possibility, or the environmental impact study eia, or in their respective environmental impact report rima. Monte task groupwas createdto update and complementthe feasibility and the environmental impact studies. Este rima j traz as principais informa es sobre o empreendimento, explica como a regi o atualmente. Mar 14, 2017 now available for free download, belo monte. Abstract environmental impact assessment eia has the goal of providing decision makers with an indication of the likely environmental consequences of planned actions risking environmental changes and, when necessary, allowing revision of these actions to mitigate adverse impacts. The temporary environmental license for the installation of the belo monte plant was granted in february 2010. The peasantsfishermen would be resettled elsewhere.
This site outlines the true cost of such a project. Belo monte is designed to be the largest plant entirely in brazil and would be the worlds thirdlargest hydroelectric project. Rima ii will integrate the old version of rima with breakpoint and will guarantee extended analysis and new tools for measuring resilience. Belo monte tera um reservatorio relativamente pequeno, embora venha aumentando as estimativas da area. The belo monte dam project navid chowdhury december 3, 2011 submitted as coursework for ph240, stanford university, fall 2011 history. Map modified based on instituto socioambiental isa geoprocessing 20, with data from ibge, funai, and the eia rima for belo monte and eia rima belo sun. In this chapter, we analyze the important position of hydroelectricity and its role in society in order to understand the brazilian energy system. It was also not perceived as a worthy position of attention by the supervisory body responsible for the design of the licenses that allowed belo monte is built, the ibama. Localizacao volta grande do xingu belo monte altamirapara transamazonica vitoria do xingu anapu brasil novo altamira senador jose porfirio. Aula inicial sobre impacto ambiental, com base na lei brasileira. Studies for the hydroelectric site began in the 1970s. Rima was completely and deeply revised by the fao resilience analysis and policies rap team. Due to lack of community consultation and negative socioenvironmental impacts, the belo monte dam in the brazilian amazon has become a prime example of how not to produce energy in the 21st century.
O eiarima da usina hidreletrica belo monte e as populacoes indigenas. According to the environmental impact report eia rima, this power plant has the capacity to produce 11,233. It was also not perceived as a worthy position of attention by the supervisory body responsible for the design of. Work on the eia began in 2000, and a draft was completed in 2002 brazil, eletronorte, sd 2002.
512 754 1010 307 509 284 84 1125 1307 571 135 1520 311 259 579 848 957 1016 983 289 1396 675 171 934 45 754 1201 1359 1300 6 622 1180 740