That kind of resultoriented justice system is a rebuke to authorities and civil rights watchdog institutions of any era, including our own. Charting the reallife events that saw a number of highranking nazi officers attempt to overthrow hitler, the movie stars tom cruise as col. The conspirator focuses on the trial of mary surratt, a washington boardinghouse. The movies historical accuracy is creating a dispute far broader than surratts fate. The persecution of martin by cornwallis army was real and based on francis marion. There are plenty of sources which agree on the major inaccuracies resulting in this movies being more of a fairy tale than a history lesson. The conspirator is a brilliantly staged depiction of a turning point in american history. White says that while not every detail of the film is true, the delicate. The movie basically deals with the story of mary surrat, a 42yearold widow who runs a modest boarding house in washington, d.
The lone woman charged, mary surratt, 42, owns a boarding house where john wilkes booth and others met and planned the simultaneous attacks. Top rated shows most popular shows browse tv shows by genre tv news india tv spotlight. With robin wright, james mcavoy, tom wilkinson, kevin kline. The realism of conspiracy refering to the hbo movie.
Character, plot, and historical accuracy suffered as a result. The film suggests that authorities suppressed evidence for fear that a long proceeding might encourage rebels. This movie is very well acted and truly conveys the emotion felt by the characters in history, unlike some civil war films. Just how historically accurate was tom cruises valkyrie. Peice of trash, tries to perpetuate the confederate myth that mary surrat was an innocent victim. The conspirator, robert redfords bold new feature about the lincoln assassination, the first movie from the american film company, is out april 15. Once the dry dust of history gets whisked away, the conspirator feels like a television movie. The conspirator is a 2010 american mystery historical drama film directed by robert redford based on an original screenplay by james d. The conspirator is a 2010 american mystery historical drama film directed by robert redford. He approaches it as a legal procedural, concerned not only with the case but with the legal precedents it established, which we are still dealing with today. A cautionary tale on such a subject is certainly a good thing. Directed by robert redford, the conspirator is a movie based on the true story of a war hero who defends a mother accused of aiding in lincolns assassination. The conspirator, robert redfords latest film, takes up the story in a postwar washington convincingly shot on location in savannah, ga. Though there had been many celebrations in washington city over.
A new movie, the conspirator, follows the trial of mary surratt, played by robin wright, after the assassination of abraham lincoln. Benjamin martin is a composite character made up of thomas sumter, daniel morgan, andrew pickens, and francis marion all whom were real people. Three greatest american archaeologists moved to accept bibles accuracy through archaeology. The civil war trusts exclusive interview with the american film companys robert stone, producer of the 2011 film the conspirator, a historical drama about mary surratt and the assassination of abraham lincoln starring james mcavoy and robin wright, directed by robert redford. Presenting her in a more realistic fashion, with all her flaws intact, would have been a more interesting story. In cold war london, young american melinda greyton dame elizabeth taylor marries british army major michael curragh robert taylor, who is a communist spy working for the soviets. With robert taylor, elizabeth taylor, robert flemyng, harold warrender.
Playing out largely as a courtroom drama, the movie uses history to explore the conflict between justice and politics and offers plenty to talk and think about. Robert redford has done a remarkable job in trying to tell a part of the story in a historically accurate manner as possible. The conspirator the facts secretary of war edwin stanton was out attending a union victory celebration the night of the assassination. So i just saw the movie the conspirator last night, opening in the district on the same day that abraham lincoln died april 15, 146 years ago i missed the red carpet premiere at fords theatre last week complete with director robert redford and all the movies stars, including robin wright, james mcavoy, and kevin cline. The conspirator is a courtroom drama about mary surratt, a confederate sympathizer accused of helping to plot abraham lincolns assassination. Francis marion was known as the swamp fox and he helped. The conspirator on dvd august 16, 2011 starring james mcavoy, robin wright, justin long, evan rachel wood. The conspirator is the first completed project of the american film company. For those of you who dont know, conspiracy stars kenneth branagh and stanley tucci and came out as a tv movie a few months ago. However, this movie has too many inaccuracies to be considered historical or a documentary. Mary surratt is the lone female charged as a coconspirator in the assassination trial of abraham lincoln. I went to see the movie the conspirator the other night and i really enjoyed it. Questions of historical accuracy were responded to at the aha session by.
Today, the 146th anniversary of president abraham lincolns death, a new historical feature film, the conspirator, opens. Names, places and events may have been changed for creative license purposes only. From the uniforms to the portrayal of the characters. The clothes in this movie are accurate for the time period.
The film tells the story of mary surratt, the only female conspirator charged in the abraham lincoln assassination and the first woman to be executed by the united states federal government. Crucially, the case tried a civilian in a military tribunal, denying her the right to a jury of. I wont give much away, but the emotional conflicts in this film are very deep and strong. Valkyrie is a 2008 thriller film directed and coproduced by bryan singer and written by christopher mcquarrie and nathan alexander. Breen writes that the historical nat, however, killed fewer white people than his fellow rebelshe failed, on a few occasions, to fully kill those he attacked and left it to a coconspirator. The film is set in nazi germany during world war ii and depicts the 20 july plot in 1944 by german army officers to assassinate adolf hitler and to use the operation valkyrie national emergency plan to take control of the country. As a civil war historian and sometimes reenactor, i have been troubled by the dearth of good films depicting the. The liberal lie, the conservative truth exposing the liberal lie through current events and history. This movie truly is about the struggle between justice and country. However, in this instance it goes a bit far and leads to an idealized and romanticized depiction of mary surratt. In the wake of abraham lincolns assassination, seven men and one woman are then arrested and charged with conspiring to kill the president. As the whole nation turns against her, she is forced to rely on her reluctant lawyer to uncover the truth and save her life. Thankfully, the conspirator presents such a high level of historical accuracy, that very little fact checking is required.
The film follows defense attorney frederick aiken as he attempts to defend mary. The film is riddled with inaccuracies, to find some of them all you have to do is go to wikipedia, robert redford said on the today show that surrat hung for 5 mins before dying, that. I had to explain to the boy who robert redford was hes seen the castle, that he was a director of some merit, and also that he was pretty far left wing, just to prepare him to see the conspirator, redfords movie about the trial of anna surratt, who was accused of conspiring to kill president lincoln so what we have is a pretty good movie that is i understand fairly reasonable in. Yet this is all done with a level of believability and at no time do you question the films historical accuracy. Specifically, the conspirator claims to be based on actual events. A controversial historical biopic, the conspirator is an impassioned political drama from director robert redford. The conspirator is the true story of mary surratt, the lone female charged as a co conspirator in the assassination of abraham lincoln. The conspirator is an entertaining film which includes more accurate historical detail than most hollywood productions, but it misses some of the larger historical truths and issues which must be. The film suggests that authorities suppressed evidence for. The conspirator 2011 following the assassination of president lincoln, seven men and one woman are arrested and charged with conspiring to kill lincoln, the vice president and the secretary of. The first thought that manifested when the end credits began to roll for the conspirator was that this film was clearly the best of robert redfords career as a director.
It has been 150 yrs since the start of the civil war. Facts this page was created to point out some the historical inaccuracies of robert redfords film the conspirator, released april 2011. Right before the conspirator came the miley cyrus movie the last song. Valkyrie is, in essence, a thriller more than it is a war movie, and its a damn good one at that. If historical accuracy is not your thing, however, do not be alienated from this fantastic film that forms a clever courtroom drama with characters you actually care about. The conspirator 2011 rotten tomatoes movie trailers.
Here is a portion of the article by claudia puig of. Since then i have been digging up facts about the trial and the people involved in the trial. Then i was reminded of another of his films, quiz show 1994 and alas, redfords most recent efforts can only be considered a tie with that brilliance. If youd like to learn the real facts, i suggest that you read the. I was wondering if anyone has had the chance to see the new hbo movie conspiracy and was wondering if anyone wanted to comment on the realism of the movie. The script was at times too weighed down by the political agenda, the dialogue stiff, the characters.
You didnt leave me nothin but a nigger, says james chaneys killer in the. The film is the firstborn of the american film company, which produces feature films about incredible, true stories from americas past. The conspirator is the first major motion picture to open during the civil war sesquicentennial and yet it begins with one of the wars closing chapters. The conspirator accurately brings lincoln assassination. That notwithstanding, i here offer some thoughts on robert redfords movie, the conspirator, which i caught last week and enjoyed very much. Parents need to know that this robert redforddirected historical drama centers on the assassination of president lincoln and its aftermath specifically, the reallife trial of mary surratt, who was accused of being part of the plot. In the wake of abraham lincolns assassination, seven men and one woman are arrested and charged with conspiring to kill the president, the vicepresident, and the secretary of state. He utilizes the story to create a metaphor about governments abuse of power. Everything you need to know about the conspirator movie 2011. Are you as tired of post911 message movies as i am. Lincoln biographer ronald white critiques the accuracy of stephen spielbergs new film about the great emancipator. The conspirator was the second major project to film in savannah after the georgia legislature did the first useful thing its done in years and set up a highly competitive set of incentives for filmmakers to shoot in this state. Im curious what others who have seen the movie think about the historical accuracy, story line and possible uses in the classroom.
210 496 903 775 403 1459 995 317 308 1023 734 1149 1164 1392 555 417 329 138 1512 1432 1108 509 980 111 443 1467 329 449 455 122 699 1370 243 85 574 1399